Jun 25, 2019

Our Wish This July Fourth Must Be to Prevail Over Logically Errant and Morally Abominable Conservative Opposition to Democracy

Conservatism is logically errant and morally abominable.

Perpend:

The universe banged into existence almost 14 billion years ago, expanding in those processes that created the earth 10 billion years later.   Simple cells took life comparatively quickly, just under a billion years after the earth formed, but not until 500 million years ago did fish swim in the sea.  Amphibians crawled onto the earth about 360 million years ago, and reptiles roamed some 60 million years after that;  then about 200 million years ago mammals moved across the surface of this planet.  Birds flew across the skies at about 150 millions years ago, and flowers bloomed some 20 million years thereafter.  But not until 60 million years ago did the earth know primates, and the Great Apes did not make their terrestrial entrance until another 40 million years had transpired.  

Not until 2.5 million years ago---  tens of millions of years after the appearance of those Great Apes---  did creatures of the genus homo appear, and life ensued another million years before representatives of that genus walked upright.  Our more immediate progenitors, of the genus homo and the species sapiens, trod the expanses of East Africa for the first time only about 200 thousand years counting backward from this year of 2019.

So we are very young:  Human beings have only been on the earth 0.000044% (forty-four millionths of one percent) of the earth’s existence and only for 0.000014% (fourteen millions of one percent) of that expanse of time since the Big Bang.

No wonder that we’ve made so many mistakes in this trial and error of a process called life.  We are, as the Lord Hamlet tells us, “a work of art,” “noble in reason,” “infinite in faculty.”  But we are still learning how to shape ourselves into the works of art that will make us worthy as the “paragons of the world,” to use our reason for creating conditions of peace, to call upon our faculties to be all that in our enormous potential we can be.


Cruelty of humanity toward humanity has been the dominant impulse for that time that humankind has walked the earth.  Early societies tended toward egalitarianism, but the caddish truculence in which the male of the species excels became the major mode of human interaction as those formations ironically called “civilization” emerged from 4,000 BCE:  For millennia thereafter, success and the title “Great” meant ability to conquer and dominate.  Athenians experimented with a very limited form of democracy, Romans evolved republican institutions of governance, Chinese developed bureaucratic position based on merit;  but even in these governing configurations, only males from the propertied classes had the privilege of citizenship or had overwhelming advantages in gaining bureaucratic position.

Even as we drew nearer to modernity, aristocrats dominated political systems.  China had its emperors, as did Japan, but in the latter emperors were mostly symbolic screens behind which a military aristocracy produced shoguns that had real power.  In Europe, aristocrats dominated the feudal Middle Ages (500-1500 CE) until the more militarily and politically successful aristocrats emerged as monarchs and assembled fiefdoms into nation-states:  Great Britain, France, Spain, Portugal, the Netherlands.  In Great Britain, the idea of limited monarchy gained materialization in the Glorious Revolution of 1687-1688, so that from that time forward a propertied British elite served via parliament as a legislative counter to monarchical power.    

By the late 18th century, the mercantile elite of Massachusetts in the thirteen colonies along the Atlantic seaboard took umbrage at parliamentary laws that threatened their class interests and incited other folk to rebellion.  By 1781 a slave-owning plantation magnate, George Washington, led the colonial forces to victory and in 1789 became the first president of the United States of America.  In addition to Washington among the first presidents, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and James Monroe also were slave owners;  and the populist president Andrew Jackson (terms spanned 1829-1837) expanded the electorate for white males but was vicious in his pro-slavery and anti-American Indian stances.

North and South tensions induced the Civil War and a truncated effort to bring former slaves into free citizenship as putatively delivered in the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments to the United States Constitution came to an end with the Compromise of 1877.  Supreme Court justices fell to new depths in their mostly morally corrupt history by ruling for segregation in Plessy v. Ferguson (1896).  Jim Crow and Black Code violations of the best features of the United States Constitution, along with 4600 lynchings between 1877 and 1965, motivated African Americans on their Great Northern Migration from 1915, even during a deeply racist phase of United States history in which Chinese, Japanese, Jews, eastern Europeans, and southern Europeans faced severe discrimination and urban squalor.

Neither these groups nor white women (the latter despite finally gaining the vote in 1920 via the 19th Amendment) advanced prospects for full citizenship until congressional liberals awoke to pass the Civil Rights Act (1964), Voting Rights Act (1965), equal economic opportunity legislation, and fair housing laws during the 1960s and early 1970s.

Congressional liberals awoke slowly but conservatives attempted to stay in their moral slumber through all of the advances wrought by Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal (1930s), seminal civil rights legislation (1960s), and the women’s movement (l960s-1970s).

Conservatives by definition prefer society as formed by the experience of past decades and centuries;  they resist change for human betterment, as witnessed by conservative opposition to abolitionism, improved labor conditions, labor union formation, female suffrage, civil rights, women’s movement, gun control, environmental legislation, and matters of gender identity.  Only when certain attitudes regarding such matters as racial and gender equality become fixed in the ether of public opinion do conservatives relent and grudgingly adjust their professedly altered views.

As we approach Fourth of July celebrations of 2019, then, readers of the Star Tribune should be clear as to the logically errant and moral abomination that is conservatism and the intellectual poverty and moral depravity of proponents such as Stephen Young, Mitch Pearlstein, George Will, and opinion page editor Doug Tice.  These commentators can always be counted on to reveal their class and gender biases and their abject blindness to the facts of history.  They revere a deeply flawed set of Founders and the Constitution they produced, evidently unaware that the United States was born as a beneficiary of Enlightenment thinking but impeded by the biases of male patricians whose personal and professional habits contradicted the very ideals the Founders advanced.

The United States has for most of its history been an unwieldy amalgam of the police state overlain with the trappings of democracy, much like South Africa from the 1950s forward in its advancement of an apartheid system modeled on the Jim Crow South.  Conservatives have energetically opposed all social and political advances at those historical junctures when leftist radicals shamed timid liberals into action for the common good.

Humanity, still in its infancy, will make many mistakes in the years and decades to come.  But we cannot afford our currently colossal mistakes to endure for centuries.  For the needed advancements in racial, gender, and environmental matters to proceed, radicals must become more persistent and liberals must be ever more deeply shamed;  conservatives, in their illogic and immorality will be useless until dragged into the brightest light of the public ether.

Thus the wish for every American this July Fourth should be that we continue to seek the democracy that we imagine ourselves to be, knowing that we must overcome conservative recalcitrance every step along the way.      

No comments:

Post a Comment