Jan 31, 2017

Culturally Responsive Teaching and Social and Emotional Learning Are Insufficient to Address the Academic Deficiencies and Knowledge-Deprivation of Students in the Minneapolis Public Schools


What do these topics from the world of knowledge have in common?

 

>>>>>    The nature of the Big Bang and the approximate age (13.8 billion years) of the universe

 

>>>>>    The evolution of life on earth, including rudimentary life forms, plants and animals, then the sequential presence of Australopithecus, homo habilis, and homo erectus, culminating in the appearance of about 100,000 years ago

 

>>>>>    The anthropological distinction between culture and civilization, with an ability to give salient representations of the first of these on earth

 

>>>>>    Major historical events and civilizations such as those of the Greeks and Romans;  Qin and Han Dynasty China;  the pre-Mughal and Mughal empires of India; the great west African empires of Ghana, Mali, and Songhai;  the key actors and ideas of the Renaissance, Reformation, and Enlightenment

 

>>>>>    The difference in the terms Christian, Protestant and Roman Catholic

 

>>>>>    The ways in which Judaism gave rise to Christianity and Hinduism gave rise to Buddhism

 

>>>>>    The historical and current differences between Shiite and Sunni Muslims

 

>>>>>    The historical currents of West Asia and Central Asia, with specific reference to the nations of Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan

 

>>>>>    The essential difference in the physics of Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein

 

>>>>>    The difference in the psychological theories and research of Sigmund Freud and B. F. Skinner

 

>>>>>    The difference between federal deficit and debt;  the structure of the U. S. federal budget;  how the latter involves fiscal policy, while the Chair Janet Yellen and the Federal Reserve Board of Governors determine monetary policy, largely independent of the executive and legislative branches

 

>>>>>    How  the Electoral College works

 

>>>>>    The many complex and nuanced meanings of such terms as liberal, conservative, and communist

 

The answer to the questions, “What do these topics from the world of knowledge have in common?,”

could be many;  my emphasis here is that my students in the New Salem Educational Initiative come to me from the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) inevitably with little information on any of these topics.  When we read serious magazine, newspaper, and journal articles;  or train to take the ACT;  I have to take great amounts of time teaching mini-courses because my students have learned so little in the abysmal MPS schools.

 

The Culturally Responsive Teaching emphasized by MPS Teaching and Learning Director Macarre Traynham;  and the Social and Emotional Learning stressed by new Superintendent Ed Graff are not ever going to address the sort of knowledge-deficiency exhibited by the students of the Minneapolis Public Schools.

 

We should by all means train our teachers to be culturally knowledgeable and responsive;  and nurture our precious young people to internalize self and mutual respect.

 

But then the goal of an excellent education should be the impartation of vast reams of knowledge so that students go forth to lives of cultural enrichment, civic preparation, and professional satisfaction.

 

Both of my nearly complete books, Fundamentals of an Excellent Liberal Arts Education;  and Understanding the Minneapolis Public Schools:  Current Condition, Future Prospect, are written in response to the terrible quality of education delivered by the Minneapolis Public Schools.

 

The first book provides the liberal arts portion (economics, political science, psychology, world religions, world history, American history, African American history, literature, fine arts, English usage, mathematics, biology, chemistry, and physics) of an excellent education that should across the K-12 years also include the technological and vocational arts.

 

The second exposes the failure of the Minneapolis Public Schools to deliver such an education and provides the philosophical and organizational underpinning that will be necessary to do so.

 

What is at stake is our ability to deliver a favorable answer to another vital question:

 

Will our nation ever be the democracy that we imagine ourselves to be?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment