Nov 9, 2020

An Assessment of Current Davis Center (Central Office) Leadership at the Minneapolis Public Schools >>>>> A Dramatic Contrast Between Incompetent Academic Lightweights and Extraordinary Talent in Other Key Roles

The following constitutes the leadership (Superintendent Ed Graff and staff members acting collectively as cabinet) of the Minneapolis Public Schools, with an assessment of effectiveness or lack thereof  >>>>>

 

Group #1     >>>>>            

 

The Supreme Talents and Effective Staff Members Among the Leadership at the Minneapolis Public Schools, in Order of Value to the District

 

Position                                                         Annual Salary

 

Senior Finance Officer 

Ibrahima Diop                                                   $163,962             

 

One of the three best in the nation at his position, Diop has taken a smoke-and-mirrors situation of de facto deep budgetary indebtedness and overseen the development of a structurally balanced budget.

 

Senior Operations Officer             

Karen Devet                                                       $166,896             

 

Devet adroitly oversees the large operations division that provides construction & maintenance, security, transportation, and food service;  she was responsible for some of the best features of the MPS Comprehensive District Design, pertinent to transportation rationalization.

 

Associate Superintendent for Special Education              

Rochelle Cox                                                     $154,669

 

Cox’s title is misleading.  For many years, the head of special education bore the title of executive director.  Cox does not oversee mainline school site principals, in the manner of the ineffective associate superintendents discussed below.  She is rather responsible for a greatly improved special education program that had been in shambles and under litigious pressure when she assumed leadership.  Cox’s work pertinent to the MPS Comprehensive District Design was superb, emphasizing placement of students receiving special education services as close to their home locations as possible and mainstreaming as much as practicable.  Cox is an educator who has high expectations and great love for the students with whose lives she has been entrusted.

 

Senior Information Officer         

Justin Hennes                                                   $158,496

 

Having served as executive director under former Chief information Officer Fadi Fadhil, Hennes has the intellectual acumen and creativity of his mentor.

 

General Counsel             

Amy Moore                                                        $163,962

 

Ably handles legal affairs for the district and oversees a highly responsive data requests service.

 

Executive Director,

Marketing & Communications

Julie Schultz Brown                                                        $139,313             

 

Schultz Brown ably oversees marketing and communications for the district;  she adroitly handled logistical matters pertinent to public meetings for consideration of the MPS Comprehensive Design, and when crises arise she oversees the delivery of well-crafted statements to the public.

 

Board & Governmental Rel.      

Ryan Strack                                                         $108,236             

 

Strack is a versatile staff member who has overseen advocacy for bond issues and now ably performs logistical functions for the MPS Board of Education, as well as establishing relationships with governmental entities.

 

Group #2    >>>>>

 

Staff Members Whose Effectiveness is Constrained by the Political Ether

 

Senior Human Resources Officer             

Maggie Sullivan                                                               $158,496

 

An enormously bright staff member who must carefully navigate contentious matters such as teacher and other staff contract negotiations, she also has an understanding of the need to upgrade teacher quality;  Sullivan, though, is constrained by a firmly entrenched education establishment and must find ways to break through daunting impediments to produce the requisite quality of teaching and academic staff excellence.   

 

Executive Officer, Superintendent Office           

Suzanne Kelly                                                   $190,038

 

Kelly was a key go-to person in the initial stages of the generation of the MPS Comprehensive District Design (CDD) and she sincerely wants to bring knowledge-intensive curriculum to MPS students;  but the academic component of the CDD became a jargon-infested document that cannot be the basis for the needed changes:  To be effective, Kelly will have to find a way to break through the bureaucratic impediments posed by the Department of Teaching and Learning and other forces of the education establishment, so as to advance the needed overhaul of the academic program.

 

Senior Accountability, Research & Equity Officer            

Eric Moore                                                                          $158,496             

 

Moore is a curious case, an enormously articulate communicator and a supreme master of data.  But Superintendent Graff has given Moore responsibilities pertinent to the generation of an academic program at which this gifted staff member has failed.  Moore has not done the reading necessary to gain comprehension of knowledge-intensive, skill-replete curriculum, and he is given to espousing noble values while acting in a careerist manner.  Moore should stick to his strength in data analysis and demure on matters pertinent to the academic program.

 

Executive Director,

Engagement and External Relations

CELINA S MARTINA                                                         $118,631             

 

Martina is a personable staff member who acts with considerable skill in public forums;  but she served as an Ed Graff flunky in the way that she oversaw public meetings pertinent to the MPS Comprehensive Design, maneuvering to jettison any tough questions relevant to the academic program;  she must find a way to handle bureaucratic pressures or forever bear the stain of sycophantic careerism.

 

Group #3     >>>>>

 

Academic Lightweights Responsible for the Knowledge-Deficient,

Skill-Deplete Curriculum and Low Teacher Quality in the Minneapolis Public Schools   

 

Superintendent of Schools        

EDWARD J GRAFF                                                            $230,000

 

Graff has proved an able administrator who has given talented Ibrahima Diop, Karen Devet, Justin Hennes, and Rochelle Cox scope to promote effective policies and programs in finance, operations, information technology, and special education respectively;  but Graff is an intellectual lightweight,  with no degree in a key subject area:  Graff himself can never be the progenitor of knowledge-intensive curriculum and substantive teacher training at the Minneapolis Public Schools.

               

Interim Senior Academic Officer             

AIMEE Y FEARING                                                            $159,580             

 

Fearing has irritatingly borne the given title for a year, effectively taking over from the hapless, failed outgoing Deputy of Academics, Leadership, and Learning Cecilia Sadler;  Fearing has an undergraduate degree in English as a Second Language (ESL) and graduate degrees in education;  she has no subject area training, has the intellectually lightweight descriptors recalling those of Graff, and has no understanding of, or ability to design, knowledge-intensive curriculum or to oversee the needed teacher training.

 

Associate Superintendent          

Ron Wagner                                                       $154,669             

 

Associate Superintendent          

Lashawn Ray                                                      $154,669             

 

Associate Superintendent          

Brian Zambreno                                               $154,669             

 

Associate Superintendent          

Shawn Harris-Berry                                         $154,669             

 

These four academically insubstantial staff members have the tragicomic role of mentoring principals.  Wagner, Ray, Zambreno, and Berry have no substantial graduate training in any key subject area.  Wagner’s degrees, both undergraduate and graduate, are all in education.  Ray and Zambreno have undergraduate training in the social sciences but otherwise have matriculated only in education programs.  Berry has an undergraduate degree in business but graduate degrees only in education;  she was bumped up in Peter Principle fashion from a failed tenure as principal at North High School, where fewer than 10% of students were proficient in reading, math, and science, and where many classes were so out of order that teachers had given up teaching.  These four associate superintendents constitute a burden on the district;  they can never be of any help in generating knowledge-intensive curriculum, and they cannot be effective as mentors of principals: 

 

The position of associate superintendent should be eliminated.

 

Group #4     >>>>>

 

Other Important Davis Center Staff Members

 

Executive Director,

English Learners & Global Education                                                                     

Muhidin Warfa                                                 $123,239

 

Warfa was listed as a member among MPS leaders until well into the 2019-2020 academic year, but Graff removed him from the cabinet when he questioned features of the MPS Comprehensive District Design relevant to language immersion programs;  to be an effective staff member for the students of the district as a whole, Warfa needs to work to master the details needed for curriculum overhaul and to develop a strategy for overcoming bureaucratic impediments.

 

Director,

Office of Black Student Achievement   

Michael Walker                                                               $137,148             

 

Walker was an effective dean of students at Roosevelt High School and has enormous communication skills;  but during the six years of his tenure at the helm of the Office of Black (formerly Male, now Student) Achievement, academic proficiency for students in the designated demographic has continued to lag;  Walker’s position and the department should be eliminated, giving way to experts with genuine academic credentials in African American and African history and culture contributing to the design of knowledge-intensive curriculum.  Walker’s skills could then be utilized in a new Department of Resource Provision and Referral, staffed with people comfortable on the streets and in the homes of students and families struggling with issues of finances and functionality.

 

Director, Indian Education          

Jennifer Rose Simon                                                      $112,565             

 

Simon came to her position after the long tenure of Anna Ross;  she is no more an academician than the latter.  The Department of Indian Education is legislatively mandated;  inasmuch as this is so, the department must be staffed with scholars knowledgeable of Native American history and able to integrate pertinent subject matter into knowledge-intensive curriculum.

 

Incompetent, Corrupt Members of the Current Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education Each Collect $20,000 Annually from Public Coffers >>>>> With Assessment of the Shortcomings of Each Member

Before promising new members Sharon El-Amin and Adriana Cerrillo, elected to the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Board of Education on 3 November, take their seats at the board’s regular meeting in January 2021, we are stuck with the membership that I assess at the end of this article. 


Of these current members, KerryJo Felder lost her District 2 (North Minneapois) seat to El-Amin and Bob Walser did not run for the District 4 (Bryn Mawr, Uptown, and surrounding areas) seat he now holds;  Cerrillo will now take that seat in January.  Unfortunately, Kim Ellison rode her name recognition (she is the ex-wife of Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison) to victory over Michael Dueñes.  But El-Amin and Cerrillo, both of whom I backed with great enthusiasm in the 3 November election, will be powerful additions to the MPS Board of Education.  Unlike the present members, all of whom are politically indebted to the Minneapolis Federation of Teachers (MFT)/Democratic Farmer Labor (DFL) party cohort, El-Amin and Cerrillo will arrive on the board uncorrupted by such indebtedness.


Keep in view as you consider the following presentation that fewer than 70% of MPS students graduate in four years, that one-third who do matriculate on college and university campuses need academic remediation, and that MPS curriculum is so weak that students who do manage to graduate walk across the stage to receive a piece of paper that is a diploma in name only.  During my six years of investigating the inner workings of the Minneapolis Public Schools, only one member (Tracine Asberry, defeated in her reelection bid in 2016) has asked consistently and persistently discerning questions of Eric Moore, the district’s senior tracker of student academic performance.  Not a single member of the current board has asked such questions, and no one among these members has questioned weak curriculum and low teacher quality, unsurprising since these members owe their positions to MFT/DFL backing.


Keeping these comments in view, be reminded that these board members each take $20,000 from public coffers per annum for such negligence.  Accordingly, each bears responsibility for their collective incompetence and corruption, and they manifest particular faults, in order of offensiveness, as follows.  These assessments are very concise versions of those given in detail in my book, Understanding the Minneapolis Public Schools:  Current Condition, Future Prospect, now circulating among select staff members at the Davis Center (MPS central offices, 1250 West Broadway) and the general public:


Current (November 2020, Post-Election But Before January 2020 Seating of New Members) Membership fo the MPS Board of Education.


Perpend, in order of offensiveness  >>>>>


MPS Board Member                    Annual Salary


Bob Walser                                          $20,000


The silliest, most trivial member of the MPS Board of Education I have witnessed in my six years of investigating the district’s inner workings;  blessedly, Walser decided not to run for reelection.


Nelson Inz                                            $20,000


A corrupt politico and MFT/DFL sycophant first elected in 2014;  he has throughout his tenure, which included a stint as board chair, failed to address the district’s most vexing dilemmas pertinent to curriculum and teacher quality.


Kim Ellison                                           $20,000


The current board chair, Ellison is another MFT/DFL politico who brings nothing of any merit to the board;  unfortunately, we are saddled with Ellison for another four years, given the name recognition that she was able to ride in prevailing in the 3 November election.


Jenny Arneson                                    $20,000


Immensely adept presider at meetings who has done stints as chair and vice-chair, Arneson’s mastery of factual detail goes to no positive purposes due to her own political corruption and inability to drive to the core of the dilemmas plaguing the district.


KerryJo Felder                                    $20,000


A false claimant to North Minneapolis leadership given to spouting data that she has failed to digest, Felder’s chief virtue has been willingness to be a thorn in the side of Superintendent Ed Graff;  she is blessedly on her way out the Davis Center door come January.


Kim Caprini                                          $20,000


Has developed some of the technical competence associated with Arneson but hamstrung and corrupted by her ties to the MFT/DFL cohort.


Ira Jourdain                                             $20,000


A member of the Red Lake Ojibwe, Jourdain makes occasional noises in the interest of equity but demonstrates little grasp of the district’s main vexations and is corrupted by his MFT/DFL associations.


Siad Ali                                                   $20,000


Hail fellow, well met, Ali occasionally gives lip service to the need for better academic performance but frequently does not do his homework and never demonstrates in-depth knowledge;  like his fellow ne’er and seldom do-wells, Ali also bears the MFT/DFL taint.


Josh Pauly                                             $20,000


Admirably concise in his comments and questions, with some indication of concern for better academic performance, Pauly nevertheless is limited by his MFT/DFL association:  Backing from that cohort was the only reason that, given the fact that at the time he was a nonentity, Pauly won his  election in 2018;  that he is the best of this corrupt assemblage is a tellingly sad comment on the corrupted nature of this current composition of the MPS Board of Education.


Thus will the arrival of Sharon El-Amin and Adriana Cerrillo in January 2021 bring integrity and independent judgment to a Minneapolis Board of Education so decidedly lacking in those qualities.   


              



Nov 4, 2020

A Great Day for the K-12 Revolution >>>>> Sharon El-Amin and Adriana Cerrillo Win Their Races for MPS Board of Education

For many years the Minneapolis Federation of Teachers (MFT)/Democratic-Farmer Labor (DFL) Party cohort has controlled the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Board of Education.  That control has been severely reduced now with the victories of Sharon El-Amin over MFT sycophant KerryJo Felder in District 2 (North Minneapolis) and Adriana Cerrillo over DFL-endorsed Christa Mims in District 4 (Bryn Mawr, Uptown, and surrounding areas).  Michael Dueñes could not overcome Kim Ellison’s name recognition for the At-Large seat, but the El-Amin and Cerrillo victories have the potential to signal a new day for the students of the Minneapolis Public Schools.

 

Here are the results of the MPS Board of Education contests, with 100% of districts reporting >>>>>

 

Hennepin County

District: Minneapolis District 4 (SSD #1)

CANDIDATE

VOTES

PCT.

Adriana Cerrillo

15,604

49.9%

Christa Mims

15,378

49.2%

100% of precincts reporting

Hennepin County

District: Minneapolis District 2 (SSD #1)


CANDIDATE

VOTES

PCT.

Sharon EL-Amin

13,377

54.9%

KerryJo Felder

10,859

44.5%

100% of precincts reporting

Hennepin County

District: Minneapolis District 6 (SSD #1)


CANDIDATE

Ira Jourdain

Uncontested

100% of precincts reporting

Hennepin County

District: Minneapolis At-Large (SSD #1)


 

CANDIDATE

VOTES

PCT.

Kim Ellison

113,459

61.3%

Michael Dueñes

70,547

38.1%

100% of precincts reporting

Oct 29, 2020

Front Matter and Contents >>>>> >Journal of the K-12 Revolution: Essays and Research from Minneapolis, Minnesota<, Volume VII, Number 4, October 2020

Volume VII, No. 4                                

October 2020

 

Journal of the K-12 Revolution:

Essays and Research from Minneapolis, Minnesota        

                                                                                

A Five-Article Series         

 

A Publication of the New Salem Educational Initiative

 

Gary Marvin Davison, Editor

                               

 

The Elevated Importance of Electing Sharon El-Amin, Adriana Cerrillos, and Michael Dueñes to the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education

 

A Five-Article Series         

 

Gary Marvin Davison, Ph. D.

Director, New Salem Educational Initiative

 

New Salem Educational Initiative

Minneapolis, Minnesota


The Elevated Importance of Electing Sharon El-Amin, Adriana Cerrillos, and Michael Dueñes to the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education

 

A Five-Article Series         

 

Copyright © 2020

 

Gary Marvin Davison

New Salem Educational Initiative

 

Contents

 

Introductory Comments                                                                                                

Electing Sharon El-Amin, Adriana Cerrillo, and Michael Dueñes for Seats on the MPS Board of Education Is Vital for Making the Needed Changes

 

Article #1                                                                                                                             

Why KerryJo Felder and Kim Ellison Must Be Ousted in the Election of 3 November---   And Why the Abdication of Bob Walser Is Such a Relief

 

Article #2                                                                                                    

Being Stuck with Ira Jourdain, Nelson Inz, Kim Caprini, Jenny Arneson, Siad Ali, and Josh Pauly Makes Voting for New Leadership All the More Important

 

Article #3                                                                                        

Incompetence of Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Superintendent Ed Graff, MPS Board of Education Members, and Consultant Paula Forbes on Full Display at Saturday, 6 April 2019 Meeting     

 

Article #4                                                                                                                          

Chronic Ineffectiveness of the Minneapolis Public Schools

Article #5                                                                                                                          

For a Chance at Attaining the Jeffersonian Vision, Electing Sharon El-Amin, Adriana Cerrillo, and Michael Dueñes to the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education Is Imperative


Concluding Comments                                                                                   

Electing Sharon El-Amin, Adriana Cerrillo, and Michael Dueñes to the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education Is Imperative for Achieving the Needed Overhaul