Dec 20, 2017

Nativity 2017

You will abide within me all through this season
that brought brightest luster to those treasures
of humanity and matter that you loved most.
 
I see your Christmas vest and skirt, your pins and
jewelry shaped in wreathes and candy canes, your
reclining Santa, your exquisite ornaments from
a world traversed widely with your beloved.
 
I bask in your smile, rejoice in your laughter rising
to match the enthusiastic peal of your mother,
as family arrived amidst hugs and banter, the time for
“having the tree” on Christmas Eve drawing near.
 
I see, smell, taste, the lovingly prepared tender turkey,
renowned dressing, oyster gravy;  the cranberry sauce,
pineapple and marshmallow salad, celery, carrot sticks.
 
You appear before me now, aglow with the transcendent
joy you felt in December 1994, when all of those whom
you loved most in the world gathered under your roof to
celebrate the season and honor the centenary of the radiant
woman of joy for whom Christmas seemed devised.
 
Deep in my heart, embedded eternally, abiding immortally,
throbs that special gift you gave to me each Christmas, that
gift you presented anew each day of my life, the only gift
that matters, the reason for our being and the season, the
 
 
Gift
 
of
 
LOVE
 
 
GMD
Christmas 2017


As most of you will recognize, I wrote this verse in honor of my mom, Betty Geer Davison (16 July 1921- 16 September 2017).

I wish all of you abundant joy with your families during Christmas and Hanukkah 2017, celebrations from other traditions, and for everybody all good fortune in New Year 2018.







Tentative Committee Memberships for the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education, 2018


In a meeting held yesterday (19 December 2017) from 4:00 until 6:00 PM, members of the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Board of Education met to express interest in positions on the various committees of the board.

 

The meeting began with a lot of banter and holiday chit-chat and ensued, as do all of the meetings of that body, without any sense of the academic crisis described by a situation in which less than 25% of African American, Hispanic, American Indian, Hmong, and Somali students are achieving grade level performance in reading and math;  and in which one-third of graduates need remedial instruction once matriculating on college campuses.

 

Peruse the following list and then await my further comment on the likelihood that the time spent on these committees is likely to result in better academic results for the students of the Minneapolis Public Schools.    

 

As you view the list, know also that Nelson Inz expressed at this meeting an interest in challenging Rebecca Gagnon as Chair of the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education.

 

>>>>>      Be keenly aware that this is just a tentative list and that positions will not be determined for final assignments until the business meeting of the MPS Board of Education in January 2018.

 

Audit Committee

 

Jenny Arneson

Rebecca Gagnon 

Ira Jourdain

Bob Walser

 

Superintendent Evaluation Committee

 

Siad Ali

Jenny Arneson

Rebecca Gagnon

Bob Walser

 

Policy Committee

 

Kim Ellison

Nelson Inz

Rebecca Gagnon (1st choice)

Don Samuels

KerryJo Felder (2nd choice)

 

Finance Committee

 

Jenny Arneson

Siad Ali

Kim Ellison

KerryJo Felder (1st choice)

Ira Jourdain

Bob Walser

Rebecca Gagnon (2nd choice)

 

 

ELL Caucus

 

Siad Ali

Kim Ellison

Rebecca Gagnon

 

Community Engagement Committee

 

KerryJo Felder

 

Achieve Minneapolis

 

1. Board Chair is automatically on this committee

2. Alt: Jenny Arneson

 

Minnesota School Board Association

 

1. Jenny Arneson

2. Kim Ellison

3. Rebecca Gagnon

 

KBEM Board

 

1. Bob Walser

2. Alt: Rebecca Gagnon

3. Alt: KerryJo Felder

 

Association of Metropolitan School Districts (AMSD)

 

1. Bob Walser

2. Alt: KerryJo Felder

 

Metropolitan Urban Indian Directors (MUID/PIE)

 

1. Kim Ellison

 

Council of Great City Schools (CGCS)

 

(Can have one representative and one alternate, need to decide who will be the representative and who will be the alternate)

 

1. Don Samuels

2. Siad Ali

 

City Planning Committee (only need one representative)

 

1. Nelson Inz

2. KerryJo Felder

 

Youth Coordinating Board (YCB) (only need two representatives)

 

1. Rebecca Gagnon

2. Don Samuels

3. KerryJo Felder

 

Minnesota Education Equity Partnership (MnEEP)

 

1. Kim Ellison

2. Alt: Rebecca Gagnon

 

Neighborhood Revitalization Program Policy Board (NRP)

 

1. Don Samuels

 

West Metro Education Program Joint Powers Board (WMEP)

 

1. Kim Ellison

2. Alt: Rebecca Gagnon

 

2020 Advisory Committee

 

1. Kim Ellison

Dec 19, 2017

Bob Walser is a Particularly Objectionable Member of a Generally Terrible Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education--- and Nelson Inz is Deeply Implicated in the Walser Abomination


Bob Walser, who in November 2016 narrowly edged Josh Reimnitz for the District #4 seat that the latter had held for four years on the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education, is the most objectionable occupant of a generally terrible compositional membership of that board.

 

Walser repeatedly wastes school board meeting time with trivial thoughts, and much of what comes out of his mouth is harmful in the extreme.  Walser has deeply imbibed the poisonous ideological brew concocted by education professors, who occupy the lowest rung of status on any college campus.  These  putative education professionals spout rhetoric devaluing the knowledge that they themselves lack, sending forth teachers severely deficient in knowledge and skill sets who cannot possibly give our students the knowledge and skill that their teachers do not possess.

 

Remember now that Amanda Ripley, in her insightful, The Smartest Kids in the World (and How They Got That Way) (2013), provides a lively summative account of facts available for many years now regarding the superiority of East Asian educational systems and others across the international landscape. 

 

After reviewing the superiority of systems in Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, Taiwan, and Shanghai (China), Ripley ultimately follows three American exchange students to the high-performing nations of Finland and, South Korea, and to Poland, whose students have been on a steady academic ascent in the course of the last twenty years.

 

Ripley cites several factors that abet elevated academic performance of students in these three nations. 

 

These nations all have the following characteristics:

 

1) rigorous national curricula;

,

2)  excellent teachers, selected from the top of their high school classes for training in prestigious, academically demanding programs specific to their fields;

 

3)  a lack of emphasis on sports;

 

4)  parents who are engaged in the academic lives of their children rather than PTA-type activities and athletic boosterism;

 

5)  students who as a matter of internalized ethic know that perseverance and diligence are more important than natural intelligence or ability; 

 

6)  whole-class instruction;

 

7)  grade by grade coherence of curriculum;

 

8)  class sizes that are large by the standards of the school systems of the United States;

 

9)  an assumption that all students can succeed.

 

With regard to the latter aspect of the most successful educational systems in the world, the children of immigrant populations and economically impoverished populations of these nations do well, because the systems are designed to serve all students in uniformly excellent schools, each institution staffed by well-paid and high-status teachers who have gained certification in highly selective teacher-training programs.

 

Students of these nations regularly far exceed the performance of students in the United States on the PISA (Program of International Student Assessment), an exam largely designed by the physicist and educator Andreas Schleicher, a German by birth who lives in Paris, where the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (the entity that sponsors PISA) is located.  The PISA exam requires a great deal of factual knowledge, with an emphasis on application and critical analysis.  In placing a great deal of importance on critical analysis and creative application, Schleicher of his own convictions constructed an assessment that answers the typical criticism of those who oppose standardized tests and are quick to offer excuses for the abysmal performance of students in the United States.

 

…………………………………………………………………………………………..

 

Bob Walser is wont to voice the ideological expostulations of education professors that run counter to the features noted in the most successful public school systems in the world.

 

Walser probably does not understand for how long we in the United States have had to endure the education-professor-speak that he delivers as if the verbiage-primed robot of these campus low-lifes.   

 

Our educational dilemma in the United States is traceable to the lamentable postulations of William Heard Kilpatrick, who at Teachers College of Columbia University from the 1920s perpetrated the anti-knowledge rhetoric that has ruined generations of teachers, victims of the erroneous expostulations of education professors.  Kilpatrick himself was under the influence of 19th century Romanticism, with its unscientific but firm faith in the potential of the unfettered individual to live well if unmarred by the strictures of society.

 

Thus do we in the United States cling to a putatively “progressive” philosophy of education that has had decisively unprogressive consequences.  Those in our education establishment and reform camps alike emphasize individualization or student and teacher generated curriculum based on personal interest, rather than on the commonly provided knowledge-intensive, skill-replete education that has moved Finland, South Korea, Poland and a bevy of other nations far ahead of students the United States on such objective measures as the PISA exam.

 

We in the United States should take our cue from Meiji japan (1868-1912) and from Taiwan during the latter’s remarkable economic ascent of the 1965-2000 era.  These geopolitical forces each surveyed the world for the best available approaches to governmental policy, catalyzing unprecedented advances in health and education.  Were we in the United States to do that, we could make everyone, including the American exceptionalists, happy by designing a system of K-12 public education that even students, families, and the general public in Finland, South Korea, Shanghai, Taiwan, and Singapore would view with awe.

 

………………………………………………………………………………………..

 

Readers should remember that in the November 2016 elections, Nelson Inz, the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of Education member from District #5, endorsed Walser’s candidacy against that of Reimnitz, a former Teach for America participant who discerns many of the problems of the education system of the United States and understands the international context given above.

 

Hence, Inz is deeply implicated in the abomination that is Walser’s presence on the current board.  Unless we can exert enough pressure on Walser to resign, or unless by some fortunate turn of events he should decide to do so, we will have to endure both Walser’s silliness and his errant rhetoric for another three years.  But we will have the chance in November 2018 to oust Inz, along with Rebecca Gagnon and Don Samuels---  in the meantime evaluating the candidacies of Jenny Arneson and Siad Ali.  

 

The K-12 Revolution that will sweep the halls of the Davis Center (central offices of the Minneapolis Public Schools, 1250 West Broadway) will bring knowledge-intensive, skill-replete curriculum and thoroughly retrained teachers to students who have been awaiting an excellent education for a very long time.

 

As we bring that overhaul for excellence, we will redesign the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) as a model for the locally centralized school district, and will place on the MPS Board of Education members who are aware of the international models for excellence and supporters of knowledge-intensive, skill-replete education.

 

Nelson Inz will be gone, and Walser will be overwhelmed with observations as to his foolishness and the insidiousness of his views.   

Dec 18, 2017

Woeful World Cafe Events Indicate Reimagine Minnesota Project Insincerity and >Star Tribune< Naivete


The enthusiasm with which the Star Tribune editorial board embraced the recommendations from the action plan recently announced by the Reimagine Minnesota project (“Another push to close education gaps,” December 16, 2017) demonstrates that board’s naivete and tendency to make recommendations that are ill-researched and based on information that comes largely from the education and political establishments, even when recommendations are purportedly reformist.

 

I attended two of the World Café events staged under the banner of Reimagine Minnesota.  The first was held at Southwest High School (Minneapolis) on February 23, 2017.  The second event was staged at the Davis Center (MPS central offices) on May 2, 2017.  The audience was a mix of parents, school personnel, and community members;  but there was also a substantial contingent of students at the Davis Center event, many of them from North High School who had responded to communications from school board member KerryJo Felder, whose district geographically spans North Minneapolis.

 

On both occasions, the head of a firm hired by the Association of Metropolitan School Districts (AMSD), promoter of the Reimagine Minnesota project, posed three questions, as follows:  1) Describe your vision of an equitable, integrated, and excellent education for all students.  What does it look like and feel like?;  2)  As you think about the challenges we face in delivering an equitable, integrated, and excellent education for all students, what is at the heart of the matter for you?  3)  (Two-part question) What are the most urgent changes we need to make to be successful in our work?  What barriers do we need to move out of the way so that our work has the chance to be successful?

 

The format utilized for discussing these questions was small-group, with seven people at a table.  That format is a defining element revealing this event as a sham.  The effort in all such formats is to confine discussion to quiet corners of the room and to dilute any comments made that condemn the education establishment by asking for reportage from a leader at each table who summarizes the conversation.  There was much in the moderator’s instructions that encouraged non-confrontational discussion and much in the nature of the reportage methods stipulated by her consulting firm that produces synthetic, consensual accounts of the discussion.

 

But at the Davis Center event, reportage did not go as the moderator doing the bidding of the AMSD wished.  School Board Chair Rebecca Gagnon gave an innocuous report for her group that the AMSD would appreciate;  and Felder issued a sloganeering, standard-issue lament about systemic racism.  I then rose to give the minority plank report not encouraged by the format, a scathing assessment of the quality of education as delivered by the Minneapolis Public Schools, indicating the prevailing absence of, but critical need for, knowledge-intensive curriculum, thorough teacher retraining, tutoring for students languishing below grade level, expanded outreach to struggling families, and bureaucratic paring.  Two young African American female teachers then rose to make their own independent, powerful, personal statements about the exact nature of racism in the classroom, hallways, and offices of K-12 institutions:

 

The recommendations as given in the action plan reported by the Star Tribune editorial board was already predicted in the way that results of discussion at the World Café events were summarized by the AMSD-hired moderator.  These recommendations called for better training for educators, improved cultural understanding among teachers and students, recruiting and retaining more teachers of color, and better shaping of instruction to meet student needs and challenges.  The first recommendation gives a gentle nod to teacher retraining, and the second and third recommendations are clearly needed; but these first three were very innocuous renderings of the assessments made by the two young African American teachers and myself.  Through the filter of Edina Superintendent John Schultz and the other AMSD superintendents, the fourth recommendation as reported by their hired hands came in a form that allows them to proceed with the sort of approach to education toward which they are currently predisposed, with emphasis on individualized programming and instruction that relies heavily on technology.

 

None of the best school systems of the world, those of the nations of East Asia and of Finland, emphasize individualized instruction or rely very much on classroom technology.  Rather, the emphasis in these most successful systems is placed on rigorous national curriculum imparted to students of all economic classes and ethnicities, and on high-quality teachers trained in selective, academically challenging programs at a limited number of colleges and universities. 

 

With regard to the naïve enthusiasm of the Star Tribune editorial board for the Reimagine Minnesota recommendation, that board has once again tossed its commentary from a tower far away from the field of action and in a cultural context of American exceptionalism.  The errant enthusiasm demonstrated by that board in this case recalls the misplaced hopes its members placed on the efforts of Generation Next, the organization once led by R. T. Rybak,  who was so sincere in his dedication to K-12 change that he has now gone on to a more highly remunerative job at the Minneapolis Foundation.

 

Star Tribune readers must realize that staff at that newspaper is too reliant on establishment and high-profile political personages for information and is abominably ill-informed as to international systems that offer indication of the constituent elements of a truly excellent education.

Dec 15, 2017

Teaching and Learning Department at the Minneapolis Public Schools is Not Fulfilling Its Mission


The following is the mission statement of the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Department of Teaching and Learning posted on the MPS website, seemingly current as of 27 September 2017:

 
Our Mission

 

Through the lens of racial equity, Teaching and Learning provides culturally relevant resources and leads the implementation of research based instructional practices that ensures that all students meet or exceed grade level standards.

 

Given the fact that MPS student academic performance is so abysmal, with fewer than 25% of African American, Hispanic, American Indian, Hmong, and Somali students achieving grade level standards in mathematics and reading, the claim that the MPS Teaching and Learning Department oversees “the implementation of researched based instructional practices that ensures that all students meet or exceed grade level standardsis a falsehood and the implication that racial equity is being achieved is likewise decidedly not true.

 

Who is most responsible for this situation at the Minneapolis Public Schools? 

Cecilia Saddler now directly oversees the MPS Department of Teaching and Learning, effectively replacing Macarre Trayham, who was deposed last spring 2017, at the same time Chief of Academics, Leadership, and Learning Michael Thomas assumed the duties formerly held by the similarly deposed Susanne Griffin.  Saddler now reports directly to Chief Thomas;  according to the best information available to me, Saddler’s title is, as of December 2017, Deputy Chief of Academics, Leadership, and Learning rather than Deputy Chief of Schools, as still given on the website.

 

Michael Thomas is among the most talented of staff members currently working at the Davis Center (MPS central offices, 1250 West Broadway).  He expresses great confidence in Saddler.  Both hold superintendent licensure.

 

But Thomas and Saddler seem to be operating under Superintendent Ed Graff’s assumption that staff training in and implementation of Social and Emotional Learning practices, along with a new K-5 reading curriculum, will bring student basic skills up to grade level and lead to quality academic programming.  As I have detailed in many articles posted as you scroll through this blog, MPS students are not making appreciable academic progress during this 2017-2018 academic year---  and they never will achieve grade level standards in mathematics and reading with a primary reliance on Social and Emotional Learning and a new K-5 reading curriculum.

Academics are the purview of Saddler and her staff at the Department of Learning.  She and that staff have much work to do, and that work must be shifted to a philosophy guided by knowledge-intensive, skill-replete curriculum of the Core Knowledge type.

Academic programming is the reason for the existence of the Minneapolis Public Schools and all locally centralized school districts.  Accordingly, I am giving much space to these matters in my nearly complete book, Understanding the Minneapolis Public Schools:  Current Condition, Future Prospect.

I have great respect for Michael Thomas and hope that his confidence in Saddler is justified.

 

The progress made in improving academic results for MPS students that I am able to report when the book attains final form in the next very few months will determine whether Thomas’s confidence is justified.

 

Here I give Saddler and the other Davis Center staff members in the MPS Department of Teaching and Learning who bear responsibility for the academic achievement of students of the Minneapolis Public Schools:

 

Teaching and Learning Staff Directory

 

2017 - 2018

 

…………………………………………..

 

Cecilia Saddler, Deputy Chief of Schools

 
612.668.0140 Telephone
 
 
………………….……………………
 
 
 
Teaching and Learning
 
Telephone  >>>>> 
 
612-668-5300
 
Fax             >>>>>
 
612-668-5305
 
 
 
 
 
Northstar Science Center
612.668.2114
612.668.2113

 

 

Administrative Support

 

Jeanne Lacy Executive Assistant        N2-056 8.5353 Jeanne.Lacy@mpls.k12.mn.us

Jake Hirschman Curriculum Assets Assistant        N2-106 8.5329 Jacob.Hirschman@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

AVID

 

Tommie Casey     9-12 AVID   Coordinator    N2-101 8.5472     Tommie.Casey@mpls.k12.mn.us

Christen Lish        K-8  AVID     Coordinator   N2-103 8.5302      Christen.Lish@mpls.k12.mn.us

Paula Kilian          6-12 AVID    Coordinator   N2-102 8.5486       Paula.Kilian@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

Elementary Team

 

Carey Seeley        Director, Elementary Education   N2-055 8.5352 787.8019  

                               Carey.Seeley@mpls.k12.mn.us

Alice Kos               K-5 Literacy DPF, Network   N2-094 8.5300   Alice.Kos@mpls.k12.mn.us

Jessica Driscoll     K-5 Literacy DPF, Network   N2-096 8.5372   Jessica.Driscoll@mpls.k12.mn.us

Julie Tangeman    K-5 Literacy / Science DPF   N2-081 8.5315   Julie.Tangeman@mpls.k12.mn.us

Kelly Meade         K-5 Literacy DPF, Network   N2-092 8.5393   Kelly.Meade@mpls.k12.mn.us

Kristi Bostad         K-5 Literacy DPF, Network   N2-093 8.5332   Kristi.Bostad@mpls.k12.mn.us

Marium Toure'     K-5 Math DPF, Davis             N2-083 8.5350   Marium.Toure@mpls.k12.mn.us

Mary Lambrecht  K-5 Math DPF, Network       N2-084 8.5361   Mary.Lambrecht@mpls.k12.mn.us

Natasha Parker    K-5 Math TOSA, Network     N2-085 8.0131   Natasha.Parker@mpls.k12.mn.us

Norma Alejandro    K-5 Literacy DPF, Network   N2-095 8.5363

                                   Norma.Alejandro-Mattson@mpls.k12.mn.us

Sara Naegeli K-5 Literacy DPF, Network            N2-082 8.5369   Sara.Naegeli@mpls.k12.mn.us

William Samsel    K-5 Math TOSA, Network      N2-086 8.0479   William.Samsel@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

K-12 Programming

 

Ashley Krohn        K-12 Library and Media          N2-071 8.0411 Ashley.Krohn@mpls.k12.mn.us

                                Information DPF

Kimberly Henscheid   SSPA Arts                            N2-074 8.5334 Kimberly.Henscheid@mpls.k12.mn.us

Nora Schull K-12 Arts DPF N2-076 8.5346 Nora.schull@mpls.k12.mn.us

Sarah Loch K-12 Health/Physical Ed DPF             N2-073 8.0418 Sarah.Loch@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

 

Material Management

 

Terry Dinovo Materials Coordinator   1225 7th St. N   8.0686   730.0473   Terry.Dinovo@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

Science Center

 

Timothy Lilla       Science Senior Materials Handler    Sci Ctr 8.2114   Timothy.Lilla@mpls.k12.mn.us

Donell Shinder    Science Materials Handler                Sci Ctr 8.2114   Donnell.Shinder@mpls.k12.mn.us

Mark Berg            Science Materials Handler                Sci Ctr 8.2114    Mark.Berg@mpls.k12.mn.us

Tara Newhouse   Senior Material Handler of               Sci Ctr 8.2112    Tara.Newhouse@mpls.k12.mn.us

                                                                    Living Organisms

 

Secondary Team

 

Dr. Naomi R. Taylor Director, Secondary Education    N2-053 8.5351 999.8207                     

                                                                    Naomi.Taylor@mpls.k12.mn.us

Chris Jones                 6-12 Math TOSA/Network    N2-075 8.5335    Chris.Jones@mpls.k12.mn.us

Chris Wernimont       6-12 Math DPF/Network      N2-062 8.5380    Christopher.Wernimont@mpls.k12.mn.us
Colleen Atakpu-         6-12 Math DPF                        N2-061 8.5373    Colleen.Atakpu@mpls.k12.mn.us

                         Shiggs

Hamdi Ahmed            6-12 Literacy TOSA/Network    N2-064 8.5374    Hamdi.Ahmed@mpls.k12.mn.us

Hibaq Mohamed        6-12 Literacy DPF                        N2-066 8.5360    Hibaq.Mohamed@mpls.k12.mn.us

Jennifer Rose              K-12 Science DPF                         N2-072 8.5341    Jennifer.Rose@mpls.k12.mn.us

Katie Stephens           6-12 Literacy DPF/Network        N2-065 8.5365    Katie.Stephens@mpls.k12.mn.us

Sarah Huffman           6-12 Literacy TOSA/Network     N2-063 8.5318    Sarah.Huffman@mpls.k12.mn.us

 

Talent Development & Advanced Academics

 

Kelly McQuillan           9-12 Talent Development          N2-052 8.5303    Kelly.Mcquillan@mpls.k12.mn.us

                                                                         /Advanced Academics

 

Theresa Campbell       K-8 Talent Development /      N2-054 8.5376     Theresa.Campbell@mpls.k12.mn.us

                                                                         / Advanced Academics