I have of late ruminated frequently concerning the low intellectual quality that I assess for the current members of the Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) Board of Education.
My
abiding question with reference to those in many quarters is, “Are they
ignorant, in denial, or outright corrupt?”
With
regard to the MPS Board of Education specifically, I have provided objective
information on all manner of subjects (classroom instruction, school
atmosphere, the knowledge deficits that I observe in students [both from MPS
and from the near suburbs], history and philosophy of education, why knowledge
and vocabulary deficits undermine ability to read advanced material and result
in low ACT performance, the decline of public education from the 1970s forward,
the dissertation of Lisa Sayles-Adams, the advent of graduate degrees for
administrators and teachers in education programs rather than
discipline-specific departments, student enrollment as a percentage of building
capacity at school sites), but all that I say seems to sail right by those in
this iteration of the MPS Board of Education.
Among the
members of this group, denial, and corruption (intellectual and moral) are
prevalent.
Increasingly,
though, my assessment is that ignorance and low intellect are major
factors. Much that I say and much that
they hear and witness seem beyond the ability of the members of this board to
process.
This then
relates to an observation of mine that I have long given great emphasis in
discussing administrator quality, whereby since the 1990s degrees in education
have dominated: for elementary school
teachers at both the bachelor’s degree and graduate degree levels, and for
secondary teachers for graduate degrees--- and from this pool doth administrators
come. This means that for all of those
making decisions as to academics or imparting academic information, almost none
are in any sense academicians, specialists, that is, in the key subject areas
taught in the classroom.
I am now
increasingly analyzing the quality of the current board membership and noting
that very few of these are academicians.
Perpend >>>>>
……………………………………………………………………….
Educational
Preparation of Current Members of the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of
Education
Collin
Beachy (At-Large)
Academic Degree/Credential
M.A.,
Autism Spectrum Disorder
(Concorida
University/St. Paul MN)
Bachelor’s
Degree, Elementary Education & Coaching
(Concordia
College/Moorehead MN)
Kim
Ellison (At-Large)
Academic Degree/Credential
Bachelor’s
Degree (unspecified major)
(Metropolitan
State University/St. Paul)
Joyner
Emerick (At-Large)
Academic Degree/Credential
No
information
Abdul
Abdi (District 1)
Academic Degree/Credential
Bachelor’s
Degree, Computer Science
(Metropolitan
State University/St. Paul, 2002)
Sharon
El-Amin (District 2)
Academic Degree/Credential
Purdue
Global (unspecified status)
Lucie
Skjefte (District 3)
Academic Degree/Credential
No
information
Adriana
Cerrillo (District 4)
Academic Degree/Credential
Associate
Arts (A.A.), Education
(State
College of Florida Collegiate School, 2000))
Lori
Norvell (District 5)
Academic Degree/Credential
Bachelor’s
Degree, Secondary Education, Mathematics, Sports Medicine
(Alderson
Broaddus University/Virginia, 1995))
Greta
Callahan (District 6)
Academic Degree/Credential
M.Ed.
(Augsburg
University, Minneapolis)
Bachelor’s
Degree, Elementary Education
(Augsburg
University, Minneapolis)
……………………………………………………………………….
Of the
current nine members of the board, then, three (Cerrillo, Skjefte, and El-Amin)
do not have a bachelor’s degree; the
latter two seem not to have even an associates degree. Of the others, only Norvell may have a
bachelor’s in a key subject area (mathematics, biology, chemistry, physics,
history, government, geography, economics, world or English literature); I am still seeking to determine if Norvell
was a genuine mathematics major or received a degree in the very different
secondary mathematics category.
Now
observe the newly elected member of the MPS Board of Education >>>>>
……………………………………………………………………….
Educational
Preparation of Newly Elected Members of the Minneapolis Public Schools Board of
Education
Christin
Crabtree (At-Large)
Academic Degree/Credential
University
of Saint Thomas
Special
Education and Teaching
Becca
Dryden (District 5)·
Academic Degree/Credential
Bachelor
of Arts
(Belmont
University, 2011 – Present)
Dryden
seems to be taking courses but as yet has obtained no degree and may not be
seeking a degree.
Christin
Crabtree (At-Large)
Academic Degree/Credential
BA,
History
(Augsburg
University, 1998 – 2003)
University
of Saint Thomas
Special
Education and Teaching
Shannon
Gibney (District 3)
Academic Degree/Credential
MFA & MA, Creative Writing & English
(Indiana University Bloomington, 1999 – 2002)
B.A.,
Creative Writing & Spanish
(Carnegie
Mellon University, 1993-1997)
Community
High School
H.S.
Diploma
1989 –
1993
Becca
Dryden’s academic status is funky.
Shannon
Gibney has the creative writing degrees, but her knowledge of literature and
breadth of reading is uncertain.
Christin
Crabtree does have a bachelor’s degree in history (from a low-tier university)
but no graduate degree.
……………………………………………………………………….
The
superintendent sitting in the midst of the Board does have a degree in
political science/government from a high-quality institution, but all of her
graduate degrees are in education, and for the doctorate she wrote an abhorrently
wretched dissertation.
Lisa
Sayles-Adams (Superintendent)
Academic Degree/Credential
Ed.D., Educational Leadership
(Minnesota State University/Mankato
2022)
M.Ed., Curriculum and Instruction
(University of Minnesota/Twin Cities. 2000)
B.A.,
Political Science and Government
(University
of Minnesota/Twin Cities, 1993-1927)
Also
worth mentioning is that the person likely to present academic information to
the Board is Melissa Sonnek (Senior Academic Officer), who has not a single
degree in a key subject area >>>>>
Melissa
Sonnek (Senior Academic Officer)
Academic Degree/Credential
M.S., Education
(Winona State University/Winona
MN)
B.A.,
Elementary Education
……………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………….
On
a given board, if one or two members are intellectually alert tradespeople
(plumbers, carpenters, mechanics), then those would have value in evaluating
Career and Technical Education (CTE) programming. But board members should be academicians,
most convincingly by formal training, and if not formally then by the evidence
of their reading and self-acquired breadth of knowledge.
For
MPS Board of Education members, as for the many teachers and administrators I
have examined, lack of academic knowledge and inclination is a very serious
impediment to making good judgments about public education.
No comments:
Post a Comment